Prediction Market vs Sportsbook Odds: Compare Kalshi to -150
Prediction market vs sportsbook odds, apples to apples: de-vig a DraftKings -150 line, add the Kalshi fee, and find the exact price where each pays more.
Comparing prediction market vs sportsbook odds on the same game takes four steps, and skipping any one of them gives the wrong answer. Take a hypothetical NFL game. DraftKings Sportsbook has the Chiefs at -150 and the Broncos at +130. Kalshi has Chiefs YES at a 59¢ ask and Broncos (Chiefs NO) at a 43¢ ask. Read raw, 59¢ converts to -144, which looks better than -150. After Kalshi's fee, the same contract trades at -154, and DraftKings pays more.
This page is the math for that one decision: which venue pays more on this bet. The broader structural differences (liquidity, market types, exits) are covered in sportsbook vs prediction market: 6 key differences. Every fee figure here renders live from our fee registry, last verified November 16, 2026.
Step 1: Convert the Kalshi Price and the Sportsbook Line to One Scale
Put both numbers on the probability scale first.
- DraftKings -150: 150 / (150 + 100) = 60.00%
- DraftKings +130: 100 / (130 + 100) = 43.48%
- Kalshi Chiefs YES at 59¢: 59%
- Kalshi Chiefs NO at 43¢: 43%
A contract price is already a probability, so the exchange side needs no formula. The sportsbook side does. If you start from a probability and want odds, the percentage to odds converter goes one way and the odds converter goes the other. The prediction market converter does cents to American directly. For every format and the after-fee version of each conversion at seven prices, read Kalshi and Polymarket prices as American odds.
These four numbers are not comparable yet. Each one includes a different kind of margin.
Step 2: De-Vig the Sportsbook Line, Then Price the Exchange Spread and Fee
The sportsbook margin sits inside the odds. The two DraftKings sides sum to 60.00% + 43.48% = 103.48%. The extra 3.48% is the overround. Divide each side by the total (the multiplicative method) and you get the book's fair line:
- Chiefs: 60.00 / 103.48 = 57.98%
- Broncos: 43.48 / 103.48 = 42.02%
The reasoning behind each de-vig method is in true odds vs implied odds, so it is not repeated here. Run the line through the de-vig calculator to see all seven methods side by side.
The exchange margin comes in two layers. The first is the spread. Kalshi's two asks sum to 59 + 43 = 102¢, an overround of 2¢. De-vig it the same way: Chiefs 59 / 102 = 57.84%, Broncos 42.16%. The two markets agree on the game within a fraction of a point.
The second layer is the fee. A Kalshi taker pays roundup(0.07 × C × P × (1 − P)) per order and nothing at settlement. Add it to both asks for 100 contracts each and compare the full cost of buying both sides:
| Market | Both sides cost, per $1 paid out |
|---|---|
| DraftKings -150 / +130 | 103.48% |
| Kalshi 59¢ / 43¢, taker | 105.42% |
| Polymarket sports 59¢ / 43¢, taker | 104.44% |
Fair probabilities tell you who the market thinks wins. They do not tell you who pays more. On this quote, the exchange's spread plus fee is a bigger margin than the sportsbook's whole overround. Price your own quote, with the venue fee turned on, in the de-vig calculator's prediction market mode or the prediction market fee calculator.
Step 3: Which Pays More on the Same Stake
The clean test: put the same dollars on the same team at each venue and compare the profit on a win.
Chiefs at Kalshi 59¢. 100 contracts cost $59.00 plus a $1.70 fee, so $60.70 in total. A win pays $100.00, for a profit of $39.30. The same $60.70 at DraftKings -150 wins $40.47. DraftKings pays $1.17 more.
Broncos at Kalshi NO 43¢. Cost $44.72, profit on a win $55.28, effective odds +124. The same stake at +130 wins $58.14, which is $2.86 more at DraftKings.
Polymarket sports at 59¢ costs less in fees ($1.21), so the gap narrows: profit $39.79 against $40.14 at DraftKings on the same stake.
Now move the Kalshi ask one cent at a time:
| Kalshi YES ask | Fee on 100 | Cost of 100 contracts | Kalshi American after fee | Kalshi profit on a win | DraftKings -150 profit, same stake | Kalshi minus DraftKings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 56¢ | $1.73 | $57.73 | -137 | $42.27 | $38.49 | $3.78 |
| 57¢ | $1.72 | $58.72 | -142 | $41.28 | $39.15 | $2.13 |
| 58¢ | $1.71 | $59.71 | -148 | $40.29 | $39.81 | $0.48 |
| 59¢ | $1.70 | $60.70 | -154 | $39.30 | $40.47 | -$1.17 |
| 60¢ | $1.68 | $61.68 | -161 | $38.32 | $41.12 | -$2.80 |
Each cent on the ask moves the comparison by about $1.65, close to the entire $1.71 fee on the order. At a 57¢ ask, Kalshi beats DraftKings by $2.13 on a ~$59 stake. At 59¢, it loses by $1.17.
The break-even price formula
You do not need a table for every line. The highest price you can pay on an exchange and still match a sportsbook line solves P + r × P × (1 − P) = S, where r is the taker rate and S is the sportsbook's implied probability. Rearranged:
P = [(1 + r) − √((1 + r)² − 4 × r × S)] / (2 × r)
For DraftKings -150 (S = 0.60) on Kalshi, that is 58.3¢. Kalshi trades in whole cents, so an ask of 58¢ or lower beats -150. The formula ignores Kalshi's per-order rounding, which moves the result by less than a cent per 100 contracts.
| Sportsbook line | Implied probability | Kalshi taker must pay at most | Polymarket sports taker | Polymarket US Tier 1 taker |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| -200 | 66.67% | 65.1¢ | 65.5¢ | 64.5¢ |
| -150 | 60.00% | 58.3¢ | 58.8¢ | 57.7¢ |
| -110 | 52.38% | 50.6¢ | 51.1¢ | 50.0¢ |
| +130 | 43.48% | 41.8¢ | 42.3¢ | 41.2¢ |
| +200 | 33.33% | 31.8¢ | 32.2¢ | 31.3¢ |
| +400 | 20.00% | 18.9¢ | 19.2¢ | 18.6¢ |
Polymarket US rounds each order's fee to the cent, and its rate falls as your 30-day volume grows, so Tier 1 is the worst case. Bookmark the row for the line you bet most. If the exchange ask is at or below the number in the row, the exchange pays more.
When the Prediction Market Wins and When the Sportsbook Wins
The intuitive answer is wrong. The exchange fee in dollars peaks at 50¢: Kalshi charges $1.75 on 100 contracts at 50¢ and $0.63 at 10¢. So it is tempting to conclude that exchanges lose near coin flips. They do not, because the sportsbook's margin is also large there. The right comparison is cents of vig on your side against cents of fee on your side.
Model a sportsbook that prices every game with the -110 / -110 overround of 4.76%, spread across both sides in proportion to each side's fair probability (the multiplicative method). The vig on a side with fair probability f is f × 4.76¢ per $1. The Kalshi fee at a fair fill is r × f × (1 − f). The exchange is cheaper whenever r × (1 − f) is smaller than the overround, which means whenever f is above 1 − overround / r.
| Fair probability of your side | Sportsbook vig on that side (4.76% overround) | Kalshi taker fee | Polymarket sports taker fee | Polymarket US Tier 1 fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | 0.48¢ | 0.63¢ | 0.45¢ | 0.86¢ |
| 30% | 1.43¢ | 1.47¢ | 1.05¢ | 2.00¢ |
| 50% | 2.38¢ | 1.75¢ | 1.25¢ | 2.38¢ |
| 70% | 3.33¢ | 1.47¢ | 1.05¢ | 2.00¢ |
| 90% | 4.29¢ | 0.63¢ | 0.45¢ | 0.86¢ |
The numbers settle it:
- Near 50/50, the exchange wins, narrowly. At a fair 50%, the sportsbook takes 2.38¢ and Kalshi 1.75¢. The fee is at its peak, but so is a meaningful share of the vig.
- On favorites, the exchange wins big. At 90%, the sportsbook's proportional vig is 4.29¢ and the Kalshi fee is 0.63¢.
- On longshots, the sportsbook wins against Kalshi. The Kalshi crossover against a 4.76% overround is a fair probability of 32%. Below it, the proportional vig is smaller than the fee. Polymarket sports crosses at 5%, and Polymarket US Tier 1 at 50%.
- Sharper lines move the crossover up. The DraftKings -150 / +130 line above carries only 3.48%. Against it, Kalshi's crossover is 50%, which is why Kalshi at a fair fill wins on the Chiefs and loses on the Broncos.
Two cautions keep this honest. First, the table assumes the exchange fills you at fair value. If the fair price sits at the midpoint of a 1¢ spread, a taker pays about half a cent above fair, which shrinks Kalshi's lead in the 50% row to 0.13¢. A 2¢ spread costs a full cent above fair and puts Kalshi 0.37¢ behind. Second, sportsbooks do not spread vig proportionally. Most shade longshots harder (the favorite-longshot bias), so the real vig on a +400 dog is often larger than the proportional model says. The de-vig calculator shows how the Shin and power methods reallocate it. Use the break-even table above for the final call on a specific bet, not the model.
Maker orders change the math again. A resting limit order avoids the spread, and Kalshi's maker rate (0.0175) applies on maker-fee series, which include almost every major sports game market. The prediction market no-vig advantage piece covers cost by price point, and sportsbook vs prediction market arbitrage covers what to do when the two venues disagree enough to bet both sides.
Settlement Rules and Taxes: What the Price Comparison Misses
Two contracts with the same probability are only the same bet if they settle the same way. Read the rules page for the exchange market before you compare.
- Overtime. NFL, NBA and NHL moneylines at US sportsbooks include overtime. Check that the exchange market resolves on the final result including overtime too, not on regulation.
- Ties and draws. A two-way NFL moneyline at a sportsbook usually grades a tie as a push and refunds the stake. An event contract settles under its own rule text, and a tie does not automatically refund you. Soccer is the larger trap: a sportsbook's three-way line settles on 90 minutes plus stoppage time, so compare an exchange "team wins" contract against the three-way price, not the draw-no-bet price, unless its rules say otherwise.
- Postponements and voids. Sportsbooks void bets on games not played within a set window. Exchange contracts have their own expiration and postponement terms. Player props differ the most: a book voids a prop when the player does not play, while a contract can settle No.
Taxes also differ, and they hit after the price. Sportsbook winnings are gambling income. For tax years beginning after December 31, 2025, the deduction for gambling losses is capped at 90% of losses, limited to your gambling winnings, and available only if you itemize. The IRS has not said how prediction market event contracts are taxed, so their treatment remains an open question. A bet that pays $2 more at a sportsbook can net less after tax for a bettor who has large gambling losses, and the reverse can hold too. The taxes hub collects the forms each venue sends, and prediction market taxes vs sports betting taxes works through three full-year examples. This is not tax advice; confirm with a tax professional.
One naming note: DraftKings also runs a separate exchange product, DraftKings Predictions, with its own fee schedule. Everything above compares against DraftKings Sportsbook. The exchange product is covered in the DraftKings prediction markets guide and the DraftKings vs Kalshi comparison.
Sources
- Kalshi fee schedule: kalshi.com/docs/kalshi-fee-schedule.pdf
- Kalshi series API (fee type and multiplier per series): api.elections.kalshi.com/trade-api/v2/series
- Polymarket trading fees: docs.polymarket.com/trading/fees
- Polymarket US fee tiers: docs.polymarket.us/fees
- Gambling loss limit, 26 U.S.C. § 165(d), as amended by Public Law 119-21, section 70114: Cornell LII
- IRS Topic 419, gambling income and losses: irs.gov/taxtopics/tc419
Frequently asked questions
- How do I compare a Kalshi price to sportsbook odds?
- Convert the sportsbook line to implied probability, add the Kalshi fee per contract to the contract price to get the effective price, then compare profit on the same stake. A Kalshi price that looks better than the sportsbook line raw can pay less once the taker fee is added.
- Are prediction market odds better than sportsbook odds?
- On favorites and near-even games filled at a fair price, usually yes, because the exchange fee per side is smaller than a standard sportsbook overround. On longshots, or when the exchange spread is wide, the sportsbook often pays more. Check the break-even price for the specific line.
- What Kalshi price beats -150 at a sportsbook?
- Solve P + r × P × (1 − P) = 0.60, where r is Kalshi's current taker rate. The break-even table on this page computes it live for -150 and five other common lines. See /fees for the current rate.
- Do I need to de-vig the sportsbook line before comparing?
- De-vigging tells you the fair probability, which is useful for judging value. To decide which venue pays more on the same bet, compare the sportsbook's raw implied probability with the exchange's price plus fee, because those are the prices you actually pay.
- Do Kalshi and sportsbooks settle the same way?
- Not always. Overtime, ties, postponements and player props can settle differently. Sportsbooks often refund a tied two-way moneyline, while an event contract settles under its own rules. Read the market's rules page first.
Related Tools
Remove the vig from bookmaker odds: 7 methods compared side by side
Odds ConverterAmerican to decimal odds and back, plus fractional and implied probability
Market ConverterKalshi and Polymarket prices to American and decimal odds, before and after fees
Fee CalculatorSee how Polymarket and Kalshi fees affect your EV
