Kalshi vs ProphetX 2026

Side-by-side fee comparison, feature checklist, and market coverage

Last updated: November 18, 2026

At a glance

RegulationKalshiCFTC-regulated designated contract market (DCM).ProphetXProphetX LLC is a CFTC designated contract market and derivatives clearing organization (order dated June 11, 2026).
Taker feeKalshi7% × p × (1−p) per contract (taker), times the series fee multiplierProphetX2% of net winnings per market, at settlement. $0 if you lose. Parlays (multi-event contracts): no fee.
Maker feeKalshi1.75% × p × (1−p) per contract on series with maker fees, which include every major sports series (NFL, NBA, NHL, college and soccer games, spreads, totals, championship futures); most other series charge makers nothingProphetXMonthly rebate of 20% to 80% of fees paid once make volume tops $50,000
Fee on 100 contracts at 50¢Kalshi$2.00ProphetX$1.00 (only if it wins)
RebatesKalshiNo fee rebates. The Liquidity Incentive Program pays $1 to $1,000 a day per selected market to resting orders, filled or not, through Jan 1, 2027.ProphetXMakers: 20% to 80% of fees paid, back monthly, once make volume tops $50,000 (marginal bands, so the rate blends as volume grows).
Tax formsKalshiFIFO profit and loss statement; 1099-INT and 1099-MISC for interest and rewards. No 1099 reports trading profit.ProphetXNo tax form published; you report profit yourself.
Not available inKalshiNo state restrictions listedProphetXNV

Fees verified November 16, 2026 against each venue's own fee schedule or API.

Fees

Depends on price

Markets

Kalshi

Regulation

Tie

Mobile

Both

Fee Comparison

Per-contract fee at 9 price points. Green = cheaper platform.

PriceKalshi FeeProphetX FeeCheaper
10¢1.00¢1.80¢Kalshi
20¢2.00¢1.60¢ProphetX
30¢2.00¢1.40¢ProphetX
40¢2.00¢1.20¢ProphetX
50¢2.00¢1.00¢ProphetX
60¢2.00¢0.80¢ProphetX
70¢2.00¢0.60¢ProphetX
80¢2.00¢0.40¢ProphetX
90¢1.00¢0.20¢ProphetX

Kalshi

7% × p × (1−p) per contract (taker), times the series fee multiplier

ProphetX

2% of net winnings per market, at settlement. $0 if you lose. Parlays (multi-event contracts): no fee.

Try your own numbers with the Fee Calculator

Rebates and rewards

Rebates only matter above the first volume tier. Below it, compare the fee table above. How rebates change your real fee.

Kalshi

  • Liquidity Incentive Program: No fee rebates. The Liquidity Incentive Program pays $1 to $1,000 a day per selected market to resting orders, filled or not, through Jan 1, 2027.
Kalshi rebate details

ProphetX

  • Make-volume rebate: 20% to 80% of fees paid, back monthly, once make volume tops $50,000 (marginal bands, so the rate blends as volume grows).
  • From Dec 1, 2026, rewards and loyalty program: Filed Nov 12, 2026, effective no earlier than Dec 1: up to 50% of fees back plus up to $2,000 a month.
ProphetX rebate details

Feature Comparison

FeatureKalshiProphetX
Open order book✓✓
Mobile app✓✓
Limit orders✓✓
Early exit / sell position✓✓
US availability✓✓
International availability✗✗
CFTC regulated✓✓
Bank deposit✓✗
Crypto deposit✓✓

Market Categories

Both platforms

PoliticsSports

Kalshi only

EconomicsWeatherFinanceCryptoCulture

Two Fee Models That Charge at Different Times

Kalshi and ProphetX are both CFTC designated contract markets. ProphetX also runs its own clearinghouse. Both list sports contracts, and ProphetX added election contracts in fall 2026. The fee models could not be more different:

  • Kalshi charges at the trade. Takers pay roundup(0.07 × C × P × (1 − P)) to the cent on every fill, win or lose, with nothing at settlement. Makers pay 0.0175 × C × P × (1 − P) on about 160 maker-fee series. That is few by count, but it covers every major sports series: NFL, NBA, NHL, college football and basketball, soccer games, spreads, totals and championship futures. Most non-sports and minor series charge makers $0.
  • ProphetX charges at settlement, only on profit. Its filed schedule takes 2% of net proceeds per market on single-event contracts. A losing market costs $0. Parlays (multi-event contracts) and RFQs carry no trading fee.

So a single trade can be cheaper on either venue, depending on the price and on whether it wins.

The Break-Even Price on a Win

On 100 contracts at price P, Kalshi's taker fee is 0.07 × P × (1 − P) × 100. A ProphetX win profits (1 − P) × 100, and the fee is 2% of that: 0.02 × (1 − P) × 100.

Set them equal:

0.07 × P × (1 − P) = 0.02 × (1 − P)

Divide both sides by (1 − P): 0.07 × P = 0.02, so P = 0.2857.

  • Below about 28.6¢, ProphetX's fee on a win is higher. A winning longshot has a large profit, and 2% of a large profit beats a small price-based fee.
  • Above 28.6¢, Kalshi's fee is higher, and the gap widens as the price rises.

Worked Table: 100 Contracts

PriceKalshi taker (win or lose)ProphetX on a winProphetX on a lossProphetX expected fee
10¢$0.63$1.80$0$0.18
20¢$1.12$1.60$0$0.32
28.6¢$1.43$1.43$0$0.41
40¢$1.68$1.20$0$0.48
50¢$1.75$1.00$0$0.50
70¢$1.47$0.60$0$0.42
80¢$1.12$0.40$0$0.32
90¢$0.63$0.20$0$0.18

The arithmetic for two rows:

  • 20¢: Kalshi roundup(0.07 × 100 × 0.20 × 0.80) = $1.12. ProphetX win: 0.02 × $80 profit = $1.60. Expected: 0.20 × $1.60 = $0.32.
  • 70¢: Kalshi 0.07 × 100 × 0.70 × 0.30 = $1.47. ProphetX win: 0.02 × $30 = $0.60. Expected: 0.70 × $0.60 = $0.42.

Compare Expected Fee, Not the Fee on a Win

Kalshi charges on every trade. ProphetX charges only on wins. Over many trades, the fair comparison is expected fee = P(win) × fee on a win.

If the price is a fair probability, P(win) = P. ProphetX's expected fee becomes P × 0.02 × (1 − P) = 0.02 × P × (1 − P). Kalshi's taker fee is 0.07 × P × (1 − P). The ratio is 0.02 / 0.07 = 2/7 at every price. ProphetX's expected fee is about 71% below Kalshi's taker fee, longshots included. The 10¢ row shows it: $1.80 on a win looks expensive, but you only pay it one time in ten, so the expected fee is $0.18 against Kalshi's $0.63.

An edge changes this. If your true win rate is q, ProphetX's expected fee is q × 0.02 × (1 − P). It passes Kalshi's only when q is above 3.5 × P. At 10¢ that means winning 35% of the time. Above 28.6¢ it needs a win rate over 100%, so Kalshi's taker fee is always higher there. Test your own price and win rate in the prediction market fee calculator and the EV calculator.

Where Kalshi Wins: Maker Orders

The expected-fee result is for takers. Makers change it.

  • Kalshi maker, non-sports and minor series: $0. ProphetX charges makers the same 2%. Kalshi wins outright. This case does not cover the sports markets ProphetX lists.
  • Kalshi maker, every major sports series (NFL, NBA, NHL, college, soccer games, spreads, totals, championship futures): 0.0175 × P × (1 − P). That is still below ProphetX's 0.02 × P × (1 − P) expected fee. At 50¢ on 100 contracts: roundup(0.0175 × 25) = $0.44 on Kalshi against an expected $0.50 on ProphetX.
  • ProphetX make-volume rebates change that last comparison at size. The monthly rebate is marginal: 0% up to $50,000 of make volume, 20% to $750,000, 40% to $3 million, 60% to $7.5 million, 80% above. At a 20% rebate, ProphetX's effective expected coefficient drops to 0.016, below Kalshi's 0.0175. A Rewards and Loyalty program filed November 12 (effective no earlier than December 1, 2026) adds up to 50% of fees back and up to $2,000 a month.

Early Exits

On Kalshi, closing early is a second taker fill. Buy 100 at 50¢ ($1.75) and sell at 60¢ (0.07 × 100 × 0.24 = $1.68): $3.43 in fees on a $10.00 gross profit.

ProphetX's filing computes the fee on net proceeds per market, at settlement. It does not spell out how a position you close before settlement is treated, so check your ProphetX statement after your first early exit before you build a strategy around it.

Per-Market Netting

ProphetX nets per market, not per account. Win $50 in one market and lose $50 in another and you are flat, but you still owe 2% × $50 = $1.00 on the winner. On Kalshi the same two trades at 50¢ cost $1.75 each, $3.50 total. ProphetX still costs less in this case, but its fee does not fall to zero just because your day did.

Markets, Regulation and Taxes

KalshiProphetX
RegulatorCFTC DCMCFTC DCM and DCO, order dated June 11, 2026
MarketsSports, politics, economics, weather, finance and moreSports first; election contracts since fall 2026
AvailabilityCheck Kalshi's eligibility pageAbout 49 states plus DC, excluding Nevada; reports of cease-and-desist orders in Connecticut and Ohio
Tax forms1099-INT, 1099-MISC, 1099-B (crypto transfers), 1099-DA; no form labeled for trading P&LCould not verify

Kalshi's tax documentation page lists the forms above and a FIFO profit and loss statement. We could not verify which form ProphetX issues. Profit on either venue is taxable whether or not a form arrives. See the prediction market vs sports betting tax guide for worked examples under each possible treatment.

Which One to Use

  • Taking the price on sports, at fair odds: ProphetX, on expected cost, at every price.
  • Resting limit orders: Kalshi. Most non-sports series charge makers $0. Major sports series charge makers 0.0175 × P × (1 − P), still below ProphetX's expected fee until ProphetX's make-volume rebate passes 12.5%.
  • Longshots where you have a large edge: run the 3.5 × P test above.
  • Economics, weather or other non-sports markets: Kalshi.
  • Pre-game sports at zero cost: Novig charges nothing pre-game. See Kalshi vs Novig.

All venues are side by side on the fees page.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is ProphetX cheaper than Kalshi?
For takers, on expected cost, yes. ProphetX charges a percentage of net winnings per market and $0 on a loss, so at fair prices its expected fee is a fixed fraction of Kalshi's taker fee, well below it at every price. On a single winning longshot below the break-even price, ProphetX's fee is higher. Current rates for both are on the fees page (/fees). For makers, Kalshi is cheaper before ProphetX's make-volume rebates: $0 on most non-sports series, and on every major sports series (NFL, NBA, NHL, college, soccer games, spreads, totals, championship futures) a maker fee that is still below ProphetX's expected fee.
Does ProphetX charge a fee on losing trades?
No. The filed fee is a percentage of net proceeds per market, calculated at settlement, so a losing market costs $0. Kalshi charges its fee on every fill, win or lose.
Is ProphetX legit?
ProphetX LLC is a CFTC designated contract market and derivatives clearing organization, with a designation order dated June 11, 2026. It is not available in Nevada, and reports say Connecticut and Ohio have issued cease-and-desist orders.
What is the break-even price between Kalshi and ProphetX?
On a winning trade, the fees are equal at P = ProphetX's rate on winnings divided by Kalshi's taker coefficient. The break-even section above shows the live price. Below it, ProphetX's percentage of a large profit is higher than Kalshi's fee. Above it, Kalshi's fee is higher.