A federal judge sent New York's suit against Kalshi back to Manhattan state court on Nov 19. The AG filed a new restraining order bid on Nov 20, Kalshi says it would force liquidation of every open position, and Justice Melissa Crane hears it Monday.
The Kalshi New York lawsuit is back where Attorney General Letitia James filed it. On Thursday, November 19, 2026, U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick of the Southern District of New York sent the case back to New York Supreme Court in Manhattan. He found the federal court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction. He also denied New York's request for attorneys' fees, finding Kalshi had reasonable grounds to remove the case.
The remand reopened the door to a temporary restraining order (TRO). An assistant attorney general filed a proposed TRO motion on Friday, November 20. Justice Melissa Crane set a hearing for Monday, November 23.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Oct 24, 2025 | NY Gaming Commission sends Kalshi a cease-and-desist |
| Jul 31, 2026 | AG files the petition in New York County Supreme Court; Kalshi removes it to federal court the same day |
| Aug 3, 2026 | Justice Crane denies the original TRO request |
| Aug 11, 2026 | CFTC emergency order under CEA Section 8a(9) calls New York's action a "major market disturbance" |
| Nov 19, 2026 | Judge Broderick remands the case to state court |
| Nov 20, 2026 | AG files a renewed TRO motion; Judge Lorna Schofield denies the federal government's bid to stop Crane from ruling |
| Nov 23, 2026 | TRO hearing before Justice Crane |
Kalshi is headquartered in New York, which is why this case matters more than any other state fight. CFTC attorney Andrew Weisberg told the federal court: "The temporary restraining order New York seeks would completely shut down Kalshi's operations nationwide." Kalshi's lawyer Sean Murphy wrote that the TRO "would likely force the liquidation of all open positions, disrupting markets far beyond this State."
The AG's office disagrees. "There has been no evidence of market disruption," said Kate Rhodes Janofsky for the state. ABC News reports the TRO targets sports contracts offered without a Gaming Commission license. Kalshi's letter quotes broader language covering "sports, culture, elections, and other events" offered "within or from New York or to persons in New York."
Press coverage puts New York's claim at "at least $36 billion." The petition itself sets no total. It asks the court for an accounting, restitution, disgorgement, damages, and two stacked penalties:
The per-offer penalty scales fast. At $100,000 each, $36 billion equals 360,000 offerings. Every 10,000 sports contracts counted as an offering adds $1 billion. The "within or from New York" wording matters here. Kalshi runs its exchange from New York, so the state's theory reaches contracts sold to traders in other states.
Three ratios put the figure in scale, using numbers from the petition and Kalshi:
| Comparison | Math | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Claim vs. Kalshi's reported valuation | $36B ÷ $22B | 1.64× |
| Claim vs. annualized volume cited by the AG | $36B ÷ $178B | 20.2% |
| Claim per New York user | $36B ÷ 1.2M users | $30,000 |
The petition also states the tax motive. In 2024, licensed New York mobile sports operators generated about $2 billion in gross gaming revenue and paid more than $1 billion in state taxes. Kalshi pays none of that, because it operates as a CFTC-registered exchange. The federal preemption argument behind that position is laid out in our CFTC prediction market rules guide.
No court has granted a TRO. If Crane grants one and Kalshi liquidates as its lawyers describe, traders lose the choice between holding and selling. Neither side has said at what price a forced liquidation would execute.
Holding to settlement on Kalshi costs nothing: there is no fee at settlement. Selling with a market order pays the taker fee, roundup(0.07 × C × P × (1 − P)). Here is the exit fee on 100 contracts and its share of the position's value:
| Exit price | Position value | Taker exit fee | Fee as % of value |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10¢ | $10 | $0.63 | 6.3% |
| 30¢ | $30 | $1.47 | 4.9% |
| 50¢ | $50 | $1.75 | 3.5% |
| 70¢ | $70 | $1.47 | 2.1% |
| 90¢ | $90 | $0.63 | 0.7% |
Longshots pay the most relative to value. A 10¢ position loses 6.3% to the fee before any spread. A 90¢ favorite loses 0.7%.
Worked example. You bought 100 YES at 30¢ and the market trades at 55¢. A market sale costs $1.74 and locks in $23.26 (entry fee aside). Holding pays +$70 if YES wins and −$30 if it loses. At a fair 55%, that is 0.55 × $70 − 0.45 × $30 = $25 of expected profit. Selling gives up $1.74 plus half the spread in exchange for certainty. A resting limit sell avoids the taker fee. On maker-fee series, which include every major sports series, it pays the maker rate instead: $0.44 on the same order. Most non-sports series charge makers nothing. Rates verified November 16, 2026.
A forced liquidation at a bad price costs far more than either fee. If a thin book clears that position at 45¢ instead of 55¢, the trader loses $10 of value before fees. Check bid depth with the liquidity calculator and price any exit with the prediction market fee calculator.
Three outcomes matter. Crane denies the TRO, as she did on August 3, and nothing changes. Crane grants a TRO limited to sports contracts for New York users, which resembles the Louisiana order where Kalshi blocked every order from affected users. Or Crane grants the broad "within or from New York" version, which Kalshi and the CFTC both say reaches every account in the country.
The appellate backdrop favors the states. The Fourth Circuit ruled against Kalshi in Maryland on November 18. The Third Circuit's New Jersey ruling is Kalshi's main win, and New Jersey has asked the Supreme Court to review it. Our Kalshi fees guide covers the full fee schedule for any position you plan to close before Monday.