# Kalshi Loses Maryland Appeal: Fourth Circuit Lets the State Enforce Gaming Law

> The Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 on November 17 that Kalshi cannot stop Maryland from enforcing its gaming law. A Maryland sports trader who moves from Kalshi to a -110 sportsbook pays more per dollar at a fair coin flip.

By Market Math Research · Updated 2026-11-18 · Published 2026-11-18

## The Kalshi Maryland ruling: what the Fourth Circuit decided

The Kalshi Maryland case ended its appeal on Tuesday, November 17, 2026. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit voted 2-1 to affirm a District of Maryland ruling that denied Kalshi an injunction. The result: Kalshi cannot block Maryland gaming regulators from pursuing enforcement over sports event contracts offered without a state license.

Kalshi sued after the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission sent it a cease-and-desist letter in 2025. Maryland agreed not to enforce its gambling laws against Kalshi while the appeal was pending. That standstill is now over. InGame reports that Maryland is free to sue Kalshi in state court and seek a ban on its sports contracts in the state.

The two judges in the majority agreed on the result and on almost nothing else:

| Judge | Vote | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Roger Gregory | Affirm | The Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) does not preempt state gambling law. "Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so." |
| Stephanie Thacker | Affirm | Sports event contracts are not swaps, so the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction over swaps does not reach them. |
| DeAndrea Gist Benjamin | Dissent | Sports contracts are swaps, and the CEA preempts Maryland's law. |

Kalshi's spokesperson: "Judges can't agree with each other on why we're wrong. This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets." Jeremy Baker, acting director of the Maryland commission, said the ruling "affirmed the state's ability to regulate what is clearly sports wagering."

## Where the circuit split stands

Reuters counts two earlier appellate losses for Kalshi and one win: the Third Circuit held that New Jersey cannot regulate it. InGame calls the Fourth Circuit the third appeals court to side with a state. Kalshi's options are a rehearing by the full Fourth Circuit or a Supreme Court petition. New Jersey already asked the Supreme Court in September to review the Third Circuit case, and InGame reports Kalshi's response is due December 7.

A split this wide is the standard trigger for Supreme Court review. Until the Court acts, the answer to "is Kalshi legal in my state" depends on which circuit you live in. The federal framework behind the fight is in our [CFTC prediction market rules guide](https://marketmath.io/blog/cftc-prediction-market-rules-2026).

## The money behind the fight: Maryland's 20% tax

Maryland raised its tax on mobile sports betting from 15% to 20% of gross revenue in 2025, after the governor first proposed 30%. Licensed sportsbooks pay that rate on every dollar of hold. Kalshi holds no Maryland license and pays Maryland no gaming tax on its sports contracts. Every Maryland bettor who trades an NFL game on Kalshi instead of a licensed app is revenue the state does not collect. That is the fiscal stake under the legal one.

## What it costs a Maryland trader if Kalshi sports contracts go away

The trader's stake is pricing. Kalshi charges a taker fee of roundup(0.07 × C × P × (1 − P)) per order and nothing at settlement. NFL series also charge makers, at a rate of 0.0175. A Maryland sportsbook prices a standard spread at -110 on both sides.

Take 100 contracts on an NFL side at 50¢, a fair coin flip, against the same bet at -110:

| Venue and order type | Cost to enter | Pays if it wins | Break-even win rate | Expected loss per $1 risked at 50% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kalshi, taker | $51.75 | $100 | 51.7% | 3.4% |
| Kalshi, maker (resting limit) | $50.44 | $100 | 50.4% | 0.9% |
| Maryland sportsbook, -110 | $110 risked | $210 returned | 52.38% | 4.55% |

The sportsbook figures come straight from the odds. At -110 you risk $110 to win $100, so you break even at 110 / 210 = 52.38%. At a true 50%, the expected result is 0.5 × $100 − 0.5 × $110 = −$5 per $110 risked.

Scale it to a season. A trader who puts $10,000 into fair coin flips loses $338.16 to Kalshi taker fees, $87.23 as a Kalshi maker, and $454.55 to -110 vig. Pushing that trader onto licensed books costs $116.39 per $10,000 against taking on Kalshi, and $367.32 against resting limit orders.

Two caveats with specifics. Kalshi's fee peaks at 50¢ and shrinks toward the edges, so the gap widens on favorites and longshots priced off a fair line. Sportsbook promos and reduced-juice lines narrow it. Price your own trade in the [prediction market fee calculator](https://marketmath.io/tools/prediction-market-fee-calculator) and compare it to the book's line with the [break-even calculator](https://marketmath.io/tools/breakeven-calculator). The full venue comparison is in [sportsbook vs prediction market](https://marketmath.io/blog/sportsbook-vs-prediction-market).

## What Maryland traders should watch

No source reports that Kalshi has blocked Maryland users. The precedent from November 14 is harsh: when Louisiana won a restraining order, Kalshi barred Louisiana users from every order, closing orders included (our [Louisiana breakdown](https://marketmath.io/news/louisiana-prediction-market-ban-cftc-lawsuit-2026) has the details). A Maryland state-court order would put open positions in the same bind.

The CFTC pulls the other way. Its November 5 interpretation of the impartial access rule gave exchanges 30 days, to about December 5, to drop state-level geographic restrictions or explain in writing why they cannot. Democratic senators asked Chairman Michael Selig on November 17 to reverse it. A Maryland order to geofence and a federal order not to geofence cannot both be obeyed. A trader holding a long-dated sports future in Maryland is carrying that conflict as risk until a court resolves it.

## Sources

- [Kalshi loses bid to prevent Maryland from policing prediction market (Reuters via Investing.com, Nov 17, 2026)](https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/kalshi-loses-bid-to-prevent-maryland-from-policing-prediction-market-5034347)
- [Fourth Circuit Sides With Maryland Over Kalshi, But All Three Judges Differ On Key Questions (InGame, Nov 17, 2026)](https://www.ingame.com/fourth-circuit-maryland-ruling/)
- [CFTC Says Exchanges Must End Geographic Access Restrictions (RG.org, Nov 2026)](https://rg.org/news/prediction-markets/cftc-impartial-access-interpretation-geofencing-prediction-markets)
- [Rosen, Cortez Masto, Senate Democratic Colleagues Push CFTC to Reverse Ban on Geofencing (Sen. Jacky Rosen, Nov 17, 2026)](https://www.rosen.senate.gov/2026/11/17/rosen-cortez-masto-senate-democratic-colleagues-push-cftc-to-reverse-ban-on-geofencing-by-prediction-markets/)
- [Maryland Governor Signs Sports Betting Tax Hike Into Law (Covers, May 2025)](https://www.covers.com/industry/maryland-governor-sign-mobile-sports-betting-tax-hike-may-2025)
- [Kalshi Fee Schedule (Kalshi)](https://kalshi.com/docs/kalshi-fee-schedule.pdf)

## Frequently asked questions

**Is Kalshi legal in Maryland after the Fourth Circuit ruling?**

No report shows Kalshi blocking Maryland users as of November 18, 2026, but the Fourth Circuit's 2-1 ruling on November 17 lets Maryland regulators pursue enforcement over its unlicensed sports contracts. The state can now sue in state court to ban them.

**Why did the Fourth Circuit rule against Kalshi?**

The two judges in the majority gave different reasons. Judge Gregory found the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt state gambling law; Judge Thacker found sports event contracts are not swaps. Judge Benjamin dissented.

**Will the Supreme Court hear a Kalshi case?**

New Jersey asked the Supreme Court in September 2026 to review the Third Circuit's pro-Kalshi ruling, and Kalshi's response is due December 7. The Fourth Circuit decision deepens the split between circuits that the Court weighs when deciding whether to take a case.

**Is Kalshi cheaper than a Maryland sportsbook?**

On a 50-cent NFL contract, yes. Kalshi's taker fee costs less per dollar risked than -110 vig at a fair coin flip, and a resting maker order costs less still. The gap is in the table above and updates with Kalshi's live fee.

**Does Kalshi pay Maryland's sports betting tax?**

No. Maryland taxes licensed mobile sportsbooks at 20% of gross revenue since its 2025 increase. Kalshi holds no Maryland license and pays no state gaming tax on its sports contracts.

---

Source: Market Math (Market Math Research), fees verified November 16, 2026. https://marketmath.io/news/kalshi-maryland-fourth-circuit-ruling-2026
