# Kalshi vs Underdog

By Market Math Research · Updated 2026-11-16

## At a glance

| | Kalshi | Underdog |
|---|---|---|
| Regulation | CFTC-regulated designated contract market (DCM) | UDM, LLC d/b/a Underdog Predict is a futures commission merchant |
| Taker fee | 7% × p × (1−p) per contract (taker), times the series fee multiplier | $0.01 per contract per side commission + exchange fee. On UDX: taker 0.07 × P × (1−P), maker 0.035 × P × (1−P). |
| Maker fee | 1.75% × p × (1−p) per contract on series with maker fees, which include every major sports series (NFL, NBA, NHL, college and soccer games, spreads, totals, championship futures); most other series charge makers nothing | Maker on UDX: 0.035 × P × (1−P) + $0.01 commission (since Oct 31, 2026) |
| Fee on 100 contracts at 50¢ | $2.00 | $2.75 |
| Tax forms | FIFO profit and loss statement; 1099-INT and 1099-MISC for interest and rewards. No 1099 reports trading profit. | 1099-B from Underdog Predict for Kalshi-routed orders; Crypto.com reports its own markets; not stated for UDX. |
| Not available in | No state restrictions listed | NY, NJ, PA, MA, AZ, CO, OH, MD, MI |

## The Same Kalshi Market, Two Ways

[Underdog Predict](https://marketmath.io/platforms/underdog) is a broker, not just an exchange. UDM, LLC d/b/a Underdog Predict is a futures commission merchant that routes your order to one of three venues: Underdog's own exchange (UDX, the former Aristotle DCM), [Kalshi](https://marketmath.io/platforms/kalshi), or Crypto.com's exchange. Reports say the ticket shows which venue filled the order.

When an Underdog order goes to Kalshi, you trade the same contract on the same order book as a Kalshi customer. The difference is one extra layer of cost: **Underdog's $0.01 per contract commission, on each side.**

- **Kalshi direct:** taker fee roundup(0.07 × C × P × (1 − P)) to the cent on every fill, nothing at settlement. Makers pay $0 on most series by count, but every major sports series (NFL, NBA, NHL, college football and basketball, soccer games, spreads, totals and championship futures) charges makers roundup(0.0175 × C × P × (1 − P)).
- **Through Underdog, routed to Kalshi:** Kalshi's fee + $0.01 × C, at open and again at close.

## Worked Examples: 100 Contracts Held to Settlement

**At 50¢, taker.** Kalshi direct: 0.07 × 100 × 0.25 = $1.75. Through Underdog: $1.75 + $1.00 = **$2.75**, 57% more.

**At 20¢ or 80¢, taker.** Kalshi direct: roundup(0.07 × 100 × 0.16) = $1.12. Through Underdog: **$2.12**, 89% more.

**Maker on a Kalshi series with no maker fee (most non-sports and minor series).** Kalshi direct: $0. Through Underdog: **$1.00**.

**Maker on a major sports series (NFL, NBA, NHL, college, soccer games, spreads, totals, championship futures) at 50¢.** Kalshi direct: roundup(0.0175 × 100 × 0.25) = $0.44. Through Underdog: **$1.44**.

| Order, 100 contracts | 20¢ | 50¢ | 80¢ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kalshi direct, taker | $1.12 | $1.75 | $1.12 |
| Underdog routed to Kalshi, taker | $2.12 | $2.75 | $2.12 |
| Kalshi direct, maker (no-maker-fee series) | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Underdog routed to Kalshi, maker (no-maker-fee series) | $1.00 | $1.00 | $1.00 |
| Kalshi direct, maker (major sports series) | $0.28 | $0.44 | $0.28 |
| Underdog routed to Kalshi, maker (major sports series) | $1.28 | $1.44 | $1.28 |
| Underdog on UDX, taker | $2.12 | $2.75 | $2.12 |
| Underdog on UDX, maker | $1.56 | $1.88 | $1.56 |

### What the Commission Does to Your Break-Even

Buy at 50¢ as a taker and your all-in cost per contract is $0.5175 on Kalshi. You need a 51.75% win rate to break even. Through Underdog it is $0.5275, so you need **52.75%**. At 80¢ the break-even moves from 81.12% to 82.12%. The commission adds one full percentage point to the win rate you need, at every price. Check whether your edge covers it with the [EV calculator](https://marketmath.io/tools/pm-ev-calculator).

## UDX Fees vs Kalshi

When Underdog routes to its own exchange, layer two is the UDX fee (schedule v3.1, effective October 31, 2026):

- **Taker:** Round(0.07 × C × P × (1 − P)), the same coefficient as Kalshi.
- **Maker:** Round(0.035 × C × P × (1 − P)). That is double the 0.0175 Kalshi charges makers on every major sports series. Kalshi makers pay nothing only on series without maker fees, which are mostly non-sports and minor markets.
- **Rounding:** to the nearest cent with halves to even. Kalshi rounds up.

The rounding difference is small but real on small orders. One contract at 20¢: Kalshi rounds 0.07 × 0.16 = $0.0112 up to $0.02. UDX rounds it down to $0.01, and the commission makes it $0.02. A tie. One contract at 50¢: Kalshi $0.02, UDX $0.02 + $0.01 = $0.03.

The UDX schedule has changed four times since August. The maker rate was 0.07 through August 19, was cut to 0.0175 on August 20, and was raised to 0.035 on October 31. Review sites that still quote Underdog at "$0.02 flat" are out of date.

## Early Exit Costs Twice the Commission

Selling before settlement is a new trade, so Underdog charges the commission again.

Buy 100 at 50¢ and sell at 60¢, both as a taker:

- **Kalshi direct:** $1.75 + 0.07 × 100 × 0.60 × 0.40 = $1.75 + $1.68 = **$3.43**. Gross profit $10.00, net $6.57.
- **Through Underdog, either venue:** ($1.75 + $1.00) + ($1.68 + $1.00) = **$5.43**. Net $4.57.

On that trade, Underdog takes 54% of your gross profit and Kalshi direct takes 34%. A trader who exits early 20 times a month at this size pays $40 more through Underdog ($2.00 × 20).

## Taxes

According to press coverage of Underdog's tax guidance, UDM issues a **1099-B** for Kalshi-routed accounts, and Crypto.com issues the form for trades routed to its exchange. Forms go out by January 31, with a $2.50 charge for a paper copy. No form has been stated for UDX-routed trades.

That creates an odd split. Kalshi's own tax documentation page lists a 1099-INT, 1099-MISC, a 1099-B for crypto transfers and a 1099-DA, with no form labeled for trading P&L. So the same Kalshi trade can come with a 1099-B when placed through Underdog and no trading form when placed directly. Your tax owed does not depend on the form. How event contracts are taxed is still open; see the [prediction market vs sports betting tax guide](https://marketmath.io/blog/prediction-market-taxes-vs-sports-betting-2026).

## Availability

Review sites reported in September 2026 that Underdog Predict was live in about 32 states, excluding New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Arizona, Colorado, Ohio, Maryland and Michigan. Treat that list as a starting point and confirm in the app.

## Who Should Use Which

**Use Kalshi directly if you:**

- Trade more than a few times a month. The commission is $1.00 per 100 contracts per side, every time.
- Use limit orders. On a major sports series at 50¢, a maker pays $0.44 per 100 direct and $1.44 through Underdog. On series with no maker fee, mostly non-sports and minor markets, it is $0 direct and $1.00 through Underdog.
- Exit before settlement. You pay the commission twice.
- Want markets beyond sports.

**Underdog Predict fits if you:**

- Already hold an Underdog account and place a handful of 100-contract trades a month held to settlement. Five such trades cost $5.00 more than Kalshi direct.
- Value one app over a lower fee, and know the price.

For other sports venues, [Novig](https://marketmath.io/platforms/novig) charges $0 on pre-game straight trades and [ProphetX](https://marketmath.io/platforms/prophetx) charges 2% of net winnings with $0 on a loss. See [Kalshi vs Novig](https://marketmath.io/compare/kalshi-vs-novig) and [Kalshi vs ProphetX](https://marketmath.io/compare/kalshi-vs-prophetx), model your order in the [prediction market fee calculator](https://marketmath.io/tools/prediction-market-fee-calculator), and compare every venue on the [fees page](https://marketmath.io/fees).

## Sources

- [Kalshi fee schedule](https://kalshi.com/docs/kalshi-fee-schedule.pdf)
- [Kalshi: what tax documentation does Kalshi provide](https://help.kalshi.com/en/articles/13823849-what-tax-documentation-does-kalshi-provide)
- [Underdog Predict (UDM) commission schedule](https://underdogpredict.pactsafe.io/versions/69b85d23240ac4b2dc86f87b.pdf)
- [UDX fee schedule v3.1, effective Oct 31, 2026](https://underdog-exchange.pactsafe.io/versions/6ae4c6f216e2f20a70ca8dfe.pdf)
- [UDX rulebook and legal documents](https://legal.underdogexchange.com/)
- [Underdog acquisition of Aristotle, CFTC filing](https://www.cftc.gov/filings/orgrules/rules0617266822.pdf)

## Frequently asked questions

**Is Underdog Predict the same as Kalshi?**

No. Underdog Predict (UDM, LLC) is a broker that routes orders to Underdog's own exchange (UDX), to Kalshi, or to Crypto.com. When it routes to Kalshi you trade the same order book, but you pay Underdog's $0.01 per contract commission on each side on top of Kalshi's fee.

**How much more does Underdog cost than Kalshi?**

$0.01 per contract per side. On 100 contracts held to settlement, Underdog costs $1.00 more than Kalshi direct, and $2.00 more on a round trip. A Kalshi maker on a major sports series (NFL, NBA, NHL, college, soccer games, spreads, totals, championship futures) pays Kalshi's maker fee of rate × C × P × (1 − P) direct (see /fees for the current rate), plus $1.00 per 100 contracts through Underdog. On series with no maker fee, it is $0 direct and $1.00 through Underdog.

**Does Underdog charge to sell early?**

Yes. The commission and the exchange fee apply to the closing trade too. Buying 100 at 50¢ and selling at 60¢ as a taker costs $2.00 more through Underdog than on Kalshi directly.

**Does Underdog charge a flat fee per contract?**

No. Review sites quoting a flat two cents are out of date. Underdog Predict charges a $0.01 commission per contract on each side plus the exchange fee: Kalshi's fee when routed to Kalshi, or the UDX fee of Round(rate × C × P × (1 − P)) with separate taker and maker rates when routed to UDX (see /fees for current rates).

---

Source: Market Math (Market Math Research), fees verified November 16, 2026. https://marketmath.io/compare/kalshi-vs-underdog
